Constructive Criticism

How to evaluate blueprints for socialism

Posted at — Nov 7, 2026 by Izzy Meckler

Beggs, Burgis, and Sunkar’s recent book “The Blueprint: How Socialism Can Work in the Real World” puts forward a concrete proposal for what they call socialism. It is a set of institutions and social practices that they believe would yield a society that is both (a) desirable – i.e., would ameliorate the issues of our current world1 – and (b) viable, that is, able to reproduce itself over time. They do not attempt to argue its “feasibility”, that we could actually get there from where we are now.

I applaud the attempt to put forward such a vision. I disagree with the overall shape of their proposal, the form of their arguments, and even specific assertions. Before getting to that however, I would like to set some standards for what a proposal for socialism should look like, and then evaluate their effort against my standards.

Imagine socialists have succeeded in winning political power.

That is: The working class is won over to socialist ideas and is sufficiently organized that it is capable of acting to transform society to socialist ends2. Let’s set The Blueprint’s political valence (technocratic) and choice of tools (bureaucracies and banks), which would probably not be taken up by an organized working class for various reasons. The working class movement has a high stakes decision before it: how will it spend its organizational capacity to reach socialism? The Blueprint does not provide sufficient evidence to justify enacting its proposals in that moment. It’s just not very convincing.

A serious proposal would, at the least:

  1. Define the problem to be solved
    1. Define a model of what a human being is. What are our needs? What kinds of social practices are we capable of? Of course you do not need to do this from whole cloth, and can draw on existing work. It doesn’t need to be a fully constrained model, and could be a very weak one simply specifying our need for food and shelter, if that is the part of the problem you aim to solve.
    2. Define a model of what social relations and institutions are
    3. Define a notion of the history produced by a set of social relations and institutions in given technological and environmental conditions
    4. Define a predicate of desirability on such histories: that they are egalitarian, provide for basic needs, etc.
  2. Construct a solution: define a set of social relations carried out through concrete practices
  3. Prove the viability and desirability of the solution.
    1. Viability: In the model, do the given social relations reproduce themselves indefinitely (under whatever environmental and technological assumptions)?
    2. Desirability: Do the histories generated by the solution satisfy the defined predicate of desirability.

Ideally, such a model would be formalized using a verification system like Lean, which is now very much achievable given the development of AI, even for non-experts. Even simulations without proofs would still be useful.

Which parts of our rubric The Blueprint achieves

How does The Blueprint fare here? Unsurprisingly nothing is modeled explicitly, but some of the above are present, albeit in fragmentary form.

To summarize: their exploration of the space of alternatives is not organized in such a principled way. It takes a few points in this space, finds them wanting, and asserts that their solution address their deficiencies via a few examples. BBS give us arguments for the desirability and viability of their society piecemeal, failing to provide convincing evidence that the practices described would reproduce themselves or produce a desirable society.

Their choice of desirability predicate

Their explicitly stated desirability predicate (Rawlsian veil of ignorance) is far too lax and permits many bad societies. Any socialist “desirability” predicate must include:

  1. The maintenance of ecological parameters within certain bounds: we consume at most this much freshwater, produce this much CO2, etc.
  2. The absence of class divisions, or a principle of social mobility: a notion that any individual could feasibly act to put themselves in any position in the production process3. This is stronger than the veil of ignorance in that the “veil of ignorance” permits immobility if it is compensated for in some way.

On their evaluation of the alternatives

This doesn’t impact their argument for their own proposal, but I wanted to mention a disagreement.

They accept Mises’ argument from 1920(!) on on the calculation debate, asserting that there is too much information to be processed by any kind of structured non-market planning system, even setting aside the incentive problems with gathering accurate information. This to me indicates serious technological illiteracy. The question of incentives for accurate information gathering is solvable as well,. Have several independent sources for any desired piece of information, offer incentives for guessing correctly (verified against the information yielding positive consequences) and take the majority opinion, perhaps weighted by people’s track record in submitting accurate information.

A more rigorously analyzed proposal

To illustrate what it would mean to examine viability, desirability, and feasibility of transition, let’s consider a proposed society, which I call “gun to the head” communism.

First of all, we should set ourselves a criterion: what would count as “communism”? Here, it will mean satisfying a “principle of social mobility”:

(Principle of social mobility.) For the overwhelming majority of the population, for any social role which is within their physical capacity to perform, they know actions they can take such that no matter where they are starting out, after a reasonable period of time they can occupy their “goal” social role.

This is a way of saying there are no classes. So how do we achieve such a utopia?

It works like this:

This satisfies the equality principle since there is exactly one social role – that of meat robot for the computer system – and therefore anyone can move from any social role to any other one (trivially). Incidentally it also clarifies what “social role” means: what situations is a person presented with, and what choices for action are available to them in those situations?

This is obviously a nightmare but is obviously viable and brings to the fore several key issues:

By the way, another reason this social mobility principle is interesting is that it implies a kind of “income equality” despite not positing it directly, assuming that one’s income (in the sense of the real goods they receive, not necessarily monetary) is determined by one’s “social role.” If that’s the case, then anyone can act to receive whatever income they would like by putting themselves in the right social role. It does immediately imply that income is equal across social roles. However, if the society is viable, and if a large shift in people’s choice of social role would threaten the viability (like if all farmers became well-paid artists), then the differences cannot be very large, as large differences would trigger social movement that would create inviability.

A systematic analysis of the space of possible social arrangements should begin by examining extreme cases such as this, where certain problems are ignored entirely, to discover the set of “levers” we are really working with, and then see how intermediate settings of the various “levers” interact.


  1. They claim a favorable evaluation against Erik Olin Wright’s list of 11 bad things about capitalism: 1. Capitalist class relations perpetuate eliminable forms of human suffering. 2. Capitalism blocks the universalization of conditions for expansive human flourishing. 3. Capitalism perpetuates eliminable defi cits in individual freedom and autonomy. 4. Capitalism violates liberal egalitarian principles of social justice. 5. Capitalism is inefficient in certain crucial respects. 6. Capitalism has a systematic bias toward consumerism. 7. Capitalism is environmentally destructive. 8. Capitalist commodification threatens important broadly held values. 9. Capitalism, in a world of nation states, fuels militarism and imperialism. 10. Capitalism corrodes community. 11. Capitalism limits democracy. ↩︎

  2. This is a premise that is totally absent from The Blueprint, which is more aimed at future technocrats rather than an organized working class. ↩︎

  3. Replace the “any"s by quantities, or probabilities to get more flexible notions of the abolition of class ↩︎